Jump to content
Carp Anglers Group Forums

michaelpthompson

CAG Member
  • Content Count

    33
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by michaelpthompson

  1. Looks like your situation is similar to what we have here in Colorado. Chumming (pre-baiting) is illegal. "It is illegal to introduce anything into waters of the state for the purpose of attempting to attract fish (e.g. chumming, artificial light, acoustic equipment, etc.) that is not attached or applied to a lure as defined" "A lure is defined as any man-made object comprised of metal, plastic, wood and/or other nonedible materials made or used to catch fish." So, if you use a method lead, or popup boilie rig, etc., you are fine as long as the bait it attached to the lure. Some here in Colorado question the use of pack baits and there seems to be some discretion among wildlife officers whether that is considered chumming. I do not consider it to be so, since I embed the hook in the packbait, and it remains attached by a hook link the entire time I am fishing. The packbait does tend to dissolve a bit and float around, but it was attached when I cast it out. An officer may disagree. I don't know, I haven't spoken with one. North Dakota regulations define bait in three categories: 1. Live bait and baitfish, 2. Terrestrial bait (such as nightcrawlers, and waxworms), and 3. Manufactured bait. "Products manufactured as edible fishing bait and other inert biodegradable substances are legal bait." Corn is not specifically manufactured to catch fish, but would certainly seem to fit within those definitions. It is certainly not prohibited. Same with bread, oats, bread crumbs, or other substances often used in carp fishing. Not specifically allowed, but it's hard to see a wildlife officer complaining about corn when nightcrawlers and salamanders are expressly allowed. As always, your mileage may vary. Game officers are very individual and may have their own definitions, especially for a species unfamiliar to them, such as carp. Another thing to keep in mind though is that the North Dakota regulations define common carp and silver carp as None-game Class III Aquatic Nuisance Species (ANS), which "can be kept for consumption if legally harvested." but "cannot be released alive back into a waterbody after they have been harvested." So apparently, catch and release carp fishing is illegal in North Dakota.
  2. Best wishes Philip. I hear they do carp fishing in Blighty too. :-)
  3. That's the way it goes in Colorado Steve. Spring was last week. But you'll be plenty nostalgic for this cold wet weather when we hit the tenth day in a row over 90°F.
  4. They have it on Walmart.com. I think you can order it and have it delivered to your local store; perhaps even your home.
  5. Thanks for the info John. Actually, I did recently obtain some Mega Tutti Frutti glug from Ken Hutchinson and started using it on my pack bait. Only one trip with it so far, but I'll keep trying.
  6. Here's an excellent video tutorial. It's not mine, but this is the way I do it.
  7. Makes sense. One of the guys I follow on YouTube is in Virginia. I'm often jealous when he spends five days prebaiting a spot, puts out 6 or eight rods, etc. In Colorado, I can have one rod, except if I buy a second rod stamp, I can have two. And chumming or baiting is strictly illegal. It's nice to know we are such a widespread, even international community.
  8. Cannonball, read back a few posts for context. In Colorado, chumming is specifically defined and PROHIBITED by our state fishing regulations. That's why it's important to check state and local laws and regs. What may be perfectly allowable in Tennessee will get you a stiff fine from a very disapproving wildlife officer in Colorado. E.G., I have gotten a lot of great advice from YouTube on carp fishing methods, but I have to ignore a fair portion of it because it's illegal in my state.
  9. CPW frowns on feeding wildlife of any sort, so even literally "feeding the ducks" would get you a ticket. So John, I fish a pack bait with my hook embedded in it. It's never softball size, just what I can pack into the contours of the lead with my hands. Maybe elongated ping pong ball size. I cast out and let it sit for 15 or 20 minutes. If it hasn't gotten any interest by then, I reel in and cast out in a slightly different spot.I can't see any way this could be considered chumming, but would love to hear your evaluation based on your conversations with wildlife officials.
  10. Sorry, but I have to disagree with the estimable Swansea Steve. Here in Colorado, the official regulations define chumming in this fashion: So, in my state the act of "regularly casting out loose method balls or cage feeders at the start of a session every 5 minutes or so" would definitely be considered a violation. I fish with a method feeder and a hair rig with the hook embedded in the pack bait, so I consider that I'm fishing with a baited hook, and therefore not chumming. I've had some people question whether wildlife enforcement would agree with my interpretation, but I have not yet been contacted while fishing, so I can't answer that question
  11. Thanks for all the great videos!
  12. Thanks John, looking forward to more carp fishing in Colorado. Been using pack bait so far, but I want to try it with my fly rod too. Met a guy at the lake on Tuesday who told me it's more like hunting than fishing. He was stalking up and down the bank, looking for cruising fish for sight casting.
  13. Thanks, I'll have to check that out next time I'm in Omaha.
  14. Thanks for the welcome John. On FishExplorer, I am michaelpthompson. Michael Thompson on Facebook. Got out fishing Tuesday afternoon in eighty degree weather. Carp were jumping all over, but none took my bait. Then our Colorado Spring rolled in with a blizzard. Nothing unusual for us.
  15. Thanks people, that's what I was thinking, but confirmation is nice.
  16. OK, this probably sounds a bit weird, but I made up some pack bait out of canned corn, strawberry jello, and bread crumbs. I haven't had a lot of time for fishing, so I have only used part of it. I kept it in the car, since the temps were pretty low, but we've had a few warm days now, and I spotted a bit of mold on it yesterday. Only a little, but it made me wonder. I know carp and catfish can and will eat decaying vegetation. Will slightly "off" bait turn them off, or make them sick, or something? Can I continue using this another day or two, or should I pitch it and make a new batch? Any advice appreciated.
  17. I haven't had rubber bands for years. I've used pieces of stick, but it takes a minute to find one the right size. I decided store bought are faster and easier. Got like five hundred of them in little lattices for three and a half bucks. The plastic is hard and durable, and there's a slot in the middle that helps keep the line in place. Just makes my life easier for a low price. jdefreitas, glad you got it figured out. It's probably a lot simpler than you thought. There should be a tiny loop at the end of your hair. Shove your baiting needle through the bait, hook the loop and pull it back through, put something in the loop to prevent it pulling back and pull it tight so the stop doesn't fall out.
  18. Wow, thanks! Those were amazing. I think the purists among us were horrified at the ways the carp were treated, being dropped on the ground and such, and certainly at the third one, but I found the whole thing fascinating. The Japanese and Chinese people in these videos had an ultimate respect for the carp as a part of their cuisine.Seems like the water quality of the carp's habitat and the preparation and cooking techniques made a huge difference in the taste of a fish that gets so much derision here in the States. I liked the whole presentation. Much faster paced and complex compared to the US version of Iron Chef. I may even have to try some simpler versions of some of those recipes.
  19. Thanks Willem, very helpful. That's what I figured about the Newbie setting.
  20. I understand why I'm listed as "Newbie" since only posted 7 times so far, but I'm curious why I'm also labeled as a "Forum Guest." I'm logged in and a paid CAG member, so what does this mean?
  21. Thanks everyone for the informative bits of your messages. I never intended this question to be a debate on catch and release. Fish are managed differently in different areas. Apparently, many of you are primarily sport and/or trophy fishers, and that makes sense when carp need to be protected. We have such fish here in Colorado too. Our official state fish, for instance, is the greenback cutthroat trout, and by law must be released immediately, except under extremely limited circumstances. It was once nearly extinct, but is now being restored to greater population, in part by catch and release. And most other game fish have bag limits appropriate to maintaining their population. It's a balance. However, in Colorado, none of this is true of carp. Carp are overabundant in many waters, and certainly not endangered in any of them, as far as I am aware. We obviously fight the image many people have of carp as a bottom feeding trash fish that destroys habitat and crowds out other fish, just as those of you "back east" do. But I could eat my fill of carp every day without affecting their population in the least. There are some who advocate killing every carp you catch because they are so prolific. I don't agree with that, but it illustrates how different our situation here is. Perhaps in the future, carp will become more popular at the dinner table and will have to be protected, but that is not true today. So for now, at least I desire to catch a couple of ten pounders and try my luck at cooking and eating them. I'l keep you posted. And yes, I will release the larger ones. Thanks again for the gracious and informative answers.
  22. Thanks for the honest answer. Right now, I'm eating pickles with hot sauce. I enjoy it very much, but not everyone appreciates it, unless they've experienced it personally. Cheers!
  23. Thanks. That's what I wound up doing, but I wasn't sure if it was the right thing, or if I had broken it.
  24. Thank you for the replies so far. I know there are differing opinions on killing carp, so don't think I have not given this much thought. There was even a discussion here on the forum where some members wondered whether catch and release was even legal in Montana, since the fish and game laws consider them a nuisance species, which by definition are not allowed to be returned to the water. I think the regulations are just poorly written, but obviously, opinions are all over the map. In my home state of Colorado, carp are officially classified as a game fish, but there is no bag or possession limit as there is with other game fish. There are numerous carp in many of our lakes and streams, and they are seriously under-fished. The pond where I am mostly interested in fishing is deeply silted and not well-maintained, resulting in an overabundance of carp, which can successfully compete with most other fish in the marginal habitat. As for size, I would not want to try cleaning a large carp anyway. I was thinking that around ten pounds would be eating size, and removing stunted fish would actually benefit the overall population. Williamson, in his article, quotes studies showing that reducing the overall population of carp in a body of water tends to result in larger carp in the long term, rather than more numerous ones. Lee, you stated that carp are not exactly the tastiest of fish. Have you actually tasted carp, or is this just based on rumor? In my research, I have run across numerous stories and videos of carp being prepared into very delicious meals. People who dismiss them as bad tasting seem to be relying more on the American opinion of them as trash fish, rather than on actual experience. I don't know if this is your situation, but as I begin my experience with carp, I wanted to make up my own mind. If I believed all the negative rumors about carp, I would never bother fishing for these nasty, bottom-feeding trash fish that do nothing but ruin the habitat and kill off all the "good" fish. :-) Thanks again for taking the time and effort to reply.
×
×
  • Create New...